My order of preference will be IIT Roorkee> IIM Sirmaur> XIMB Bhubaneswar> SIOM Nashik. When considering which institution to choose for an MBA, several factors should be taken into account.
Here are some points to consider regarding IIM Sirmaur, IIT Roorkee, SIOM Nashik and XIMB Bhubaneswar:
| Parameter | IIM Sirmaur | IIT Roorkee | SIOM Nashik | XIMB Bhubaneswar |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| NIRF Management Ranking 2023 | 98 | 18 | N/A | 46 |
| Establishment Year | 2015 | 1998 | 2005 | 1987 |
| Average Package | 14.45 | 18.34 | 14.35 | 16.64 |
| Recruiting Companies | Deloitte, Accenture, Cognizant, Schneider Electric, Hero Motors etc. | IDBI Bank, Kotak Mahindra Bank, IBM, BHEL etc. | Arrow Textiles Limited, Delta Finochem, Atlas Copco India Limited etc. | PwC, Deloitte, Goldman Sachs, Coca-Cola, L'Oreal, Nestle, Tata Steel, Amazon etc. |
Even though IIMs have a strong reputation in India for their management courses, IIM Sirmaur is quite new. It will take time to establish its brand name. SIOM is an older management institute but it is private, as opposed to IIM Sirmaur and IIT Roorkee. XIMB is a good institute, but its fees are high as compared to others.
I would recommend you choose IIT Roorkee for an MBA because of its affordable fees, top class infrastructure, and a well established brand name.
To begin with, NITIE Mumbai College exclusively admits engineering students. Non-engineers are not accepted. Therefore, if you are not an engineer, you cannot apply to NITIE. Below is a table showing the pros and cons of the two colleges;
|
Pros and Cons |
IIM Calcutta |
NITIE Mumbai |
|
Reputation |
High |
Good |
|
Curriculum |
Holistic, international exposure |
Specialized programs |
|
Faculty |
Highly qualified, industry experience |
Strong industry ties |
|
Fees |
High |
Relatively low |
|
Competition |
Highly competitive |
Less competitive |
|
Brand value |
Strong |
Good, but not as strong as IIM Calcutta |
|
Location |
In the heart of the city |
Suburban area |
Below is a table showing and comparing the two colleges on different aspects;
|
Aspect |
IIM Calcutta |
NITIE Mumbai |
|
Student-Faculty Ratio |
8:1 |
11:1 |
|
Highest CTC |
INR 1.37 CPA (2022) |
INR 78.20 LPA |
|
Average CTC (2023) |
INR 35.07 LPA |
INR 25.27 LPA |
|
Top Recruiters |
Amazon, Accenture, Deloitte, Goldman Sachs, McKinsey & Company |
Bosch, Capgemini, Cognizant, Infosys, L&T |
|
Fees |
INR 23 lakhs (for MBA) |
INR 16.85 lakhs (for MBA) |
The ultimate choice boils down to your goals, preferences, and some other constraints you might have, like if you are from an engineering background or not. Hope it helps.
I have a friend who is also an MBA Finance enthusiast. He was shortlisted for Great Lakes, Gurgaon- specifically for Finance. My answer would be more conversational and definitely does not intend to be any sort of advice as eventually, it is your call.
For studies, Great Lakes is a good choice to opt for. But here, what happens to be even more prioritized is the job profile of working under Finance.
The industry of Finance specifically has a range of 10% of jobs to offer along with 50% reserved for marketing and for operations, which is 30%. Last year, 21% of the recruiters were from BFSI out of only a small range of 10% were provided a job in Finance. Others are compelled to opt for sales. Many students end up opting for it as MBA Finance leaves them indebted and they are in dire need of a job to pay off the loan.
If you have enough confidence, do go for it. But then, if you consider yourself to be and stay your average self, there is something you need to work on.
One of the best business schools in India, the Indian Institute of Management, Kozhikode (IIM-K) offers a two-year, full-time MBA program. The curriculum is created to give students a solid grounding in management principles as well as the abilities and know-how necessary to succeed in the corporate world.
IIM-K alumni are frequently hired by a significant number of prestigious businesses and placement rates there are usually regarded as favorable. The average compensation for MBA graduates in the 2020–2022 class is approximately INR 20.5 LPA, and the highest income provided is approximately INR 57 LPA, according to the institute's placement report.
Pros of earning an MBA at IIM-K include
Among the drawbacks of an MBA at IIM-K are:
It is important to note that the advantages and disadvantages are based on common perceptions and may change depending on the individual's experiences.
IBS Hyderabad is a tier 2 college that offers MBA programs in Finance, Marketing, Operations, and Human Resources.
MBA program is relatively difficult, with the first year being slightly more difficult. The first year is rigorous, with 9 topics in Sem 1 and 8 subjects in Sem 2. Marketing management, Economics, HR, OB, and Accounting Management are among the topics covered.
Case studies are used extensively in the classes. The subjects are the same for everyone in the first year and then differ depending on the specialism in the second.
There is a mix of experienced and novice teachers on the faculty. You will be fortunate if Mr. Shailendra Bisht (one of the greatest faculty members) teaches you marketing.
The application cost for the 2019-2021 batch is 14 lakhs, with an average package of 5.5-6 lakhs (+- 10%).
So, it would take a person around two and a half years to recoup their investment, and keep in mind that I am not accounting for the opportunity cost of the two years spent in the MBA program.
Staff Selection Commission (SSC) will land you in a government job. There are different departments in SSC where you can get placed. Whereas, MBA from SIBM Bangalore will weave you to be corporate ready and land you in a private white-collar job.
Choice
|
Career |
Fee |
|
MBA from SIBM Bangalore |
INR 16.20 Lakhs |
|
SSC |
The application fee is less than INR 1000. Reserved candidates get exemption in this fee. The coaching fee will cost under INR 1 Lakh. |
If you have already cleared SSC Tier-1 and Tier-2 exams, leaving SSC will not be a wise choice. SSC is a preferable choice over MBA from SIBM Bangalore. The reason is, MBA from SIBM Bangalore does not have much credibility in the industry.
According to the reviews online, NICMAR is famous for construction management in Hyderabad. It offers one-year programs and two-year full-time programs.
The choice of the course depends on you considering the various factors like course curriculum, risk capacity in terms of return on investment, and fee. The following can be considered.
Overall, the institute offers decent placements with a 99.2% placement record in all the programs. Therefore, it is suggested that you choose according to your needs and career goal.
The career growth offered by the new IIMs is difficult to analyze as they haven’t been established for long. One cannot infer their worth easily as its alumni are yet to establish themselves in the corporate world. It will take a few more years to determine the growth of CEO alums career-wise.
If you are concerned about the general job prospects, try going through the placement reports of these IIMs. You will get a general idea of the packages and roles offered.
To know if the new IIMs are worth going for, you need to check what you are expecting from these B Schools. If you are looking for basic learning and a small push to kickstart your career, the new IIMs will benefit you. But if you are on the lookout for high ROI, the new IIMs may or may not satisfy your expectations.
The decision between Great Lakes Gurgaon PGDM and PUMBA MBA Pharma depends on a number of factors, such as your career objectives, interests, and top priorities. Here is some information about the institutes.
Great Lakes Gurgaon PGDM is a prestigious program with a comprehensive curriculum and outstanding placement opportunities. The program's strong brand name and positive reputation in the industry can be advantageous for career advancement. The program has a high ROI, with an annual salary compensation averaging between 13 and 14 lakhs.
PUMBA MBA Pharma, on the other hand, is a specialized program focused on the pharmaceutical industry. The program has a solid reputation in the pharmaceutical industry and provides adequate placement opportunities. However, the ROI may not be as high as Great Lakes Gurgaon PGDM.
Great Lakes Gurgaon PGDM attracts students from diverse academic disciplines, including engineering, commerce, and science. The program's rigorous selection process ensures that only students with a solid academic foundation and outstanding leadership potential are admitted. The PUMBA MBA Pharma programme attracts students from the pharmaceutical and life sciences industries and offers a diverse learning environment.
The choice between Great Lakes Gurgaon PGDM and PUMBA MBA Pharma ultimately depends on your career objectives and interests. Great Lakes Gurgaon PGDM could be a preferable option if you are interested in pursuing a general management program with a focus on data analytics and digital transformation. PUMBA MBA Pharma may be a better match if you wish to pursue a specialized program in the pharmaceutical industry.
All three colleges are similar in facilities and placements. mentioned institutes.The comparison below would be helpful in analysing between the three,
|
Criteria |
IMS Ghaziabad |
JIMS Rohini |
IILM Lodhi road |
|
Fees/annum |
795,000 |
86,400 |
1,290,000 |
|
Average Salary |
4 |
6.5 |
5 |
|
Highest Salary |
19 |
18 |
18 |
|
Recruiters |
KPMG, EY, Airtel, AXIS Bank, ITC Limited |
Deloitte Black Rock HDFC Bank, EY Goldman Sachs, Gartner |
ICICI, Deloitte, Federal Bank |
|
Degree |
PGDM |
PGDM |
MBA |
JIMS (Jagan Institute of Management Studies)has good visiting faculties from SRCC, LSR and other DU reputed colleges. The syllabus pedagogy is up to date with industry standards but suffers from lack of industry exposure. The institute also brings in sales roles in reputed firms like YES Bank, Standard Chartered, 99 acres etc.
IILM Lodhi Road offers a full-fledged MBA degree recognized by UGC instead of a diploma. The curriculum followed is inspired by reputed institutes around the world like Stanford, Wharton etc. Excellent in campus hostel facilities and a mentorship program for new joiners into the institute. It is popular for its offering in marketing roles and faculties in the marketing and sales domain.
IMS Ghaziabad consists of Atal Incubation centre to encourage entrepreneurship and business-minded individuals to start their own firms. There are smart classrooms, and the campus is WiFi enabled. The faculties are highly qualified and knowledgeable.
From above we can almost conclude that all three colleges are similar in facilities and placements. Choosing any one of the three would be a good decision for pursuing an MBA degree.