IITs and NITs have always been the first priority of the students seeking admission into engineering colleges. According to NIRF engineering ranking 2020 IIT Dhanbad and MNNIT Allahabad secure 15th and 48th positions respectively. IITs and NITs are known for the projects prepared by their students. Whether it is academics, placement, extracurricular activities they do excel in each field.
Admission:
For admission into MNNIT Allahabad students need to obtain a good rank in the JEE main exams and the cut-off for the CSE branch is 1269-3101.
Students seeking admission into IIT Dhanbad need to qualify for the JEE main exams. Selected candidates in the JEE mains again have to appear for the JEE Advance. The cut-off for petroleum branches is 6060-7385.
For admission into MTech courses, the qualifying exam remains the same that is GATE.
Facilities:
IIT Dhanbad offers a home-like atmosphere to its students. The Digital library, hostels, cafeteria, gymnasium are some of the facilities available.
Facilities provided at MNNIT include a book and stationery shop, free wi-fi connectivity, clubs, a stereo system, and a lot more.
Faculty:
IIT Dhanbad has a diverse group of faculty that includes 335 highly qualified faculty. Out of 335, 315 faculty members are Ph.D. holders in their respective fields.
MNNIT Allahabad has also a good number of faculty who graduated from national and international universities.
Course fees:
The course fee includes hostel, mess, health care, gymnasium, and a lot more. Students who avail of the hostel and mess facility will have to pay a little more.
Per year course fee for BTech at IIT Dhanbad is INR 2.3 Lakhs and INR 86000 at MNNIT.
The MTech per year course fee at IIT Dhanbad is INR 57000, and INR 1.13 lakhs at MNNIT.
Placements:
IIT Dhanbad never fails to maintain an impressive placement record. 75% of students were placed from the petroleum branch. The highest package offered was 21 lakhs.
In the recent placement drive, 98% of students were placed from the Computer Science branch. The highest package offered was 36 LPA and the average package offered was 16 LPA at MNNIT.
To help economically weaker students both the colleges provide scholarships. Exposure is given to research and development, with the help of highly experienced faculty. The national rankings reflect both the colleges are a good option for the students. Both colleges have impressive placement records. It solely depends on the student to choose the branch of his/her choice.
Both IIT BHU and MNNIT Allahabad are old and well-reputed colleges and offer good CSE programs in terms of academics and placements.
Being an old NIT, MNNIT Allahabad offers decent placement and the placement rate for CSE at this institute is around 97.60%. In the 2019, 163 students were placed out of 167 students from the CSE department and the average CTC offered was around 15.12 LPA. Whereas, the highest CTC went up to 36 LPA. IIT BHU had a 100% placement from the CSE department and the average CTC ranged between 10 LPA to 58 LPA.
But IIT BHU offers a better coding culture than MNNIT Allahabad. In IIT BHU almost every student gets engaged in coding, irrespective of their branch which makes for a rich coding culture on the campus. Many students were selected in Google Summer of Coding (GSoC) in 2018. Many freshers start competitive coding from the very beginning of their course. The programming society is quite active here, students participate in technical activities and various coding competitions. The results of inter IIT coding competitions are proof of IIT BHU’s growing popularity in coding.
Both MNNIT Allahabad and BIT Mesra are highly ranked technology colleges offering amazing placement opportunities to their students. NIRF and India Today ranked BIT Mesra at 38 and 2 respectively for its B.Tech course, whereas MNNIT was ranked at 48 for B.Tech in India 2020 by NIRF and 14 by India Today.
MNNIT’s last year placement ranking has seen a rise in the pay packages and the best placement record of almost 97%. BIT Mesra on the other hand holds a stellar placement record since its inception. But while selecting between IT at MNNIT Allahabad or CS at BIT Mesra one needs to consider certain facts which are discussed below.
Particulars |
MNNIT Allahabad – B.Tech Information Technology |
BIT Mesra – B.E. Computer Science and Engineering |
Fees |
Rs. 3.24 lakhs |
Rs. 13.15 LPA |
Entrance Criteria |
10+2 in science with 75% & JEE Main |
Cleared 10+2 in PCM & JEE Main |
Total Seats |
105 |
123 |
Placement Opportunities:
MNNIT Allahabad –
Almost 285 companies visited MNNIT for campus recruitments including top-tier companies such as Adobe, Accenture, Deloitte, Dell, BPCL, etc.
792 students out of 1174 were successfully placed in some of the top companies with the highest package offered in 2019 being INR 36 Lakhs (Per Annum) and the average package offered was 7.82 Lakhs (Per Annum).
The median salary offered to the students was recorded to be 8 LPA.
BIT Mesra –
BIT Mesra is renowned for the amazing placement opportunities that it has in store for the students. Some of the top recruiter companies visiting there campus are Wipro, SAP, Oracle, Microsoft, etc.
In the year 2019, 120 companies participated in the campus recruitment and offered jobs to 831 students. The highest package offered was INR 49.76 Lakhs (Per Annum), whereas the average salary offered was INR 11.76 Lakhs (Per Annum).
Whereas, the median salary was 8 LPA.
Both MNNIT Allahabad as well as BIT Mesra have seen a considerable increase in their placement opportunities for almost all courses. It depends more on the student’s interest and feasibility to choose between Information Technology at MNNIT Allahabad or Computer Science Engineering at BIT Mesra.
For the most part, it depends upon how careful you are with your budget. Commonly, local trips, note print-outs, and books take up a quarter of the expenses. Generally speaking, the major portion of expenses technically results from the food facilities you avail of.
You can avail food from the hostel mess three times per day. Typically, the food quality can range anywhere from average to bad. However, the provision of food from the hostel mess is still quite acceptable, especially if you are a vegetarian.
Having said that, you can most likely find yourself making frequent trips to several food joints situated both in and out of the campus. Apart from that, you can pay a visit to the Civil Lines about once or twice a month at a minimum as well.
The food joints and restaurants situated in Allahabad are quite affordable when compared to other mega metropolitan or metropolitan cities. Which is to say, an average of about INR. 3000 to INR. 3500 can be quite enough to pass through a month if discreetly spent.
On the flip side, if you can manage well with the food facilitated by the mess, then you can conveniently take down your expenses to about INR. 2000 per month.
If your main goal is to study economics, maths and statistics then opting for IPM at IIM Indore would be a very good idea. However, the fee structure is very high. INR 4,00,000 per annum for domestic students and for international students, it is INR 6,00,000.
You will also have to study subjects which you will necessarily not like such as sociology, psychology, etc.
Another drawback is that there is no degree for IPM. You will only get a certificate from IGNOU.
In the case of NIT Allahabad, it is a reputed institute for engineering. You will be able to study subjects that meet your interests. The fees are also very less. In the placement drive of 2020, the highest package offered to the students was INR 49 LPA. Some of the top recruiters were IBM, Adobe, Accenture, Tata Steel, Capgemini, etc. The average package was INR 10.28 LPA.
IT from MNNIT Allahabad is the better choice. The following are the support points.
Category | NIT Goa | MNNIT Allahabad |
Average CTC | INR 7.35 LPA | INR 10.28 LPA |
Highest CTC | INR 20 LPA | INR 49 LPA |
Top recruiters | TCS, R&D, Samsung | Google, Infosys, Biyus |
Overall, MNNIT will offer better opportunities as compared to NIT Goa.
On an overall basis, MNNIT Allahabad is generally considered one step ahead of COEP, Pune.
The reason behind it is that MNNIT is a well-reputed, prestigious institute that recently got placed at rank 3rd in the list of top NITs in India. On the flip side, COEP Pune is a common government college of India.
MNNIT is better in terms of placements, infrastructure, research and development cell, alumni network, sports activities, funds disbursement, faculty, and others, as opposed to COEP Pune. The table below gives a brief comparison of the two institutes.
Institute |
MNNIT Allahabad |
COEP, Pune |
Highest CTC |
49 LPA |
39 LPA |
No of students selected |
757 |
607 |
Major recruiters |
IBM, JP Morgan, Byju’s |
ABB, BOSCH, Akash Institute |
If you have to choose between both of them, going for MNNIT Allahabad will be a better choice because there can hardly be any comparisons between an NIT and a government-run college of India.
To know which institution to be preferred, let us start with the rankings of both of them. #48th is the ranking of MNNIT by NIRF for the year 2020 and on the other hand #103 is the ranking of IIIT Allahabad by NIRF for the same year. Now you can see some other factors to decide which institution can be preferred over the other.
Admissions
MNNIT:
IIIT Allahabad:
Some basic highlights about the institutions are as follows:
MNNIT Allahabad |
IIIT Allahabad |
|
Highest salary offered |
36 LPA |
36 LPA |
Average salary offered |
12.97 LPA |
15.12 LPA |
Total Number of companies visited |
250 |
120+ |
Placements:
IIIT Delhi:
MNNIT Allahabad:
Now based on all the above-mentioned data, the candidate can compare and come to the conclusion. Other factors that can be made into considerations are city life (which will be almost equivalent for both of them), faculties (highly qualified teachers are there in both the institutions), campus life, hostel facilities, etc. But at the end of the day, it is the subject and the interests of the students that matters for a successful future. IT is a good subject regarding future and the candidate can choose whichever institution suits him/her better.
Yes, MNNIT Allahabad offers the facility for parents to stay. There is a guest house which is known as the EDC guest house where the parents may accommodate for a few days The guesthouse is a great option if you're looking for comfortable and affordable accommodations during your visit. It is located on the campus of MNNIT Allahabad behind the academic building near the girl’s hostel.
To avail the same, one has to visit the EDC building and fill up the form. If rooms are available then you’ll get the accommodation easily. Or they may access the permission to stay from O.C. - EDC through the concerned Warden.
The rooms are quite spacious and fitted with a geyser. This accommodation facility is free for the administrative and academic guests recommended by the director. Moreover, this guest house of MNNIT Allahabad provides a dining facility for which you have to inform a few hours prior and also pay separately.
Among all the options you have mentioned, the one which you should actually consider is ECE in IIIT Allahabad for a duration of 5 years.
The closing rank of IIIT Allahabad is better than ECE at NIT Allahabad and IT at IIIT Allahabad. ECE is best pursued at MNNIT Allahabad rather than IIIT Allahabad. But then I should also mention that IT is better for IIIT Allahabad than anywhere else. That's a fact.
If you have a knack for coding and it holds your concern, the environment that is accurate for a coding culture can be provided by IIIT Allahabad.
Therefore, if coding and IT are your forte, a 5-year IT course at IIIT Allahabad is the one for you. The faculty there are experienced and carry specializations that guide you through your way.
Look at the bigger picture which holds your future and then go for an aim. Choose such a specialization that ensures security to your future as well.
But then, if you eventually want to settle on ECE, MNNIT is the right place.