Question

What is the effect of the question in lines 59-62?

• A. It suggests that sharing ethnicity and language might not be enough to make one an insider.
• B. It eliminates the distinction between insider and outsider.
• C. It refutes the claim that being an outsider is an important criterion for doing research.
• D. It suggests that only those with an outsider's perspective can see things objectively.
• E. It suggests that human sympathy is more important than ethnicity or language.

Hint:

When reading academic passages, pay attention to the author's challenge to assumptions about insider/outsider roles in research. This can help you identify the deeper implications of the text.

Answer 1

The Correct Option is A

Step 1: Understanding the context.
The question in lines 59-62 challenges the assumption that shared ethnicity and language automatically make someone an insider in a research context. The author suggests that being an insider requires more than just these superficial similarities.

Step 2: Analyzing the options.
- (A) "It suggests that sharing ethnicity and language might not be enough to make one an insider" directly reflects the author's challenge to the assumption of what makes an insider in research.
- (B) "It eliminates the distinction between insider and outsider" misrepresents the passage, as the author is questioning the criteria, not eliminating the distinction.
- (C) "It refutes the claim that being an outsider is an important criterion for doing research" is not the central focus; the question is more about what makes someone an insider.
- (D) "It suggests that only those with an outsider's perspective can see things objectively" is not what the question implies; the author is questioning the assumption, not asserting that only outsiders can be objective.
- (E) "It suggests that human sympathy is more important than ethnicity or language" is not directly related to the question being asked.

Step 3: Conclusion.
Option (A) best aligns with the passage's message, suggesting that shared ethnicity and language are not sufficient to define an insider.