Select Goal &
City
Select Goal
Explore
Comprehension
In relation to Native American tribes, the idea of sovereign immunity is referred to as "tribal immunity." According to court decisions, Congress cannot have comprehensive jurisdiction over tribes under the Indian Commerce Clause unless it agrees to any litigation against a tribe. However, the concept of tribal immunity was developed by courts rather than politicians.
A Supreme Court justice has questioned whether tribal immunity is still applicable and stated that it would need to be reevaluated in the future, underscoring the need for a more thorough investigation of the idea. The Supreme Court created the idea in the United States v. United States Fidelity and Guaranty Co. ruling, ruling that Indian tribes are exempt from lawsuits unless Congress gives permission. The two main grounds for this exception, according to the Court, are the protection of tribal resources and the recognition of tribes as independent entities.
As the Court has emphasized in recent years, tribes are nonetheless endowed with all sovereign powers until specifically abrogated by Congress or proven to be inconsistent with their status. It is believed that they possess these types of talents naturally because of their restricted sovereignty. The Supreme Court has cited other cases that amply illustrate the crucial notion, even if it did not directly state it as a basis. Unlike the immunity of states, the federal government, and foreign nations, tribal immunity is unrestricted. Courts still use a broad interpretation of this doctrine, often declaring that a defendant—whether a state, local government, the federal government, or a foreign country—would be sued in state or federal courts.
For example, courts have often held that a tribe's immunity can only be waived with the tribe's or Congress's express consent. Implied exemptions are not usually upheld, in contrast to other governments, especially when tribal people do business on or off reservations. Purchasing insurance does not grant immunity as well. Tribal immunity therefore goes beyond that granted to states, the Native American tribes are not treated differently from other sovereign organizations when it comes to their economic or governmental activity. According to court rulings, it makes no difference if a tribe runs governmental, commercial, or private businesses. As such, tribal immunity continues to be more extensive than that of any other sovereign.
A Supreme Court justice has questioned whether tribal immunity is still applicable and stated that it would need to be reevaluated in the future, underscoring the need for a more thorough investigation of the idea. The Supreme Court created the idea in the United States v. United States Fidelity and Guaranty Co. ruling, ruling that Indian tribes are exempt from lawsuits unless Congress gives permission. The two main grounds for this exception, according to the Court, are the protection of tribal resources and the recognition of tribes as independent entities.
As the Court has emphasized in recent years, tribes are nonetheless endowed with all sovereign powers until specifically abrogated by Congress or proven to be inconsistent with their status. It is believed that they possess these types of talents naturally because of their restricted sovereignty. The Supreme Court has cited other cases that amply illustrate the crucial notion, even if it did not directly state it as a basis. Unlike the immunity of states, the federal government, and foreign nations, tribal immunity is unrestricted. Courts still use a broad interpretation of this doctrine, often declaring that a defendant—whether a state, local government, the federal government, or a foreign country—would be sued in state or federal courts.
For example, courts have often held that a tribe's immunity can only be waived with the tribe's or Congress's express consent. Implied exemptions are not usually upheld, in contrast to other governments, especially when tribal people do business on or off reservations. Purchasing insurance does not grant immunity as well. Tribal immunity therefore goes beyond that granted to states, the Native American tribes are not treated differently from other sovereign organizations when it comes to their economic or governmental activity. According to court rulings, it makes no difference if a tribe runs governmental, commercial, or private businesses. As such, tribal immunity continues to be more extensive than that of any other sovereign.
Question: 1
According to the passage, which of the following statements about tribal immunity is NOT true?
According to the passage, which of the following statements about tribal immunity is NOT true?
Updated On: Sep 13, 2024
- Tribal immunity is based on recognizing Native American tribes as sovereign entities.
- Courts have consistently applied tribal immunity with restrictions similar to state governments.
- Tribal immunity can only be waived by the express consent of the tribe or by an act of Congress.
- Tribal immunity is broader than those enjoyed by states, the federal government, and foreign countries.
Hide Solution
Verified By Collegedunia
The Correct Option is B
Solution and Explanation
The Correct Option is (B):Courts have consistently applied tribal immunity with restrictions similar to state governments.
Was this answer helpful?
0
0
Question: 2
Based on the passage, which statement provides the most plausible explanation for why the doctrine of tribal immunity has not been subject to more scrutiny or restriction?
Based on the passage, which statement provides the most plausible explanation for why the doctrine of tribal immunity has not been subject to more scrutiny or restriction?
Updated On: Sep 13, 2024
- Native American tribes have historically maintained their sovereignty as recognized by federal laws.
- The federal government has consistently supported tribal autonomy through legislative measures.
- Tribal immunity has been consistently challenged by state governments seeking jurisdiction over tribal lands.
- Supreme Court decisions have explicitly limited the scope of tribal immunity in recent decades.
Hide Solution
Verified By Collegedunia
The Correct Option is A
Solution and Explanation
The Correct Option is (A):Native American tribes have historically maintained their sovereignty as recognized by federal laws.
Was this answer helpful?
0
0
Question: 3
Suppose a new Supreme Court decision re-examined the grounds for tribal immunity, focusing on protecting tribal resources as a less significant factor. How would this development impact the interpretation of tribal immunity discussed in the passage?
Suppose a new Supreme Court decision re-examined the grounds for tribal immunity, focusing on protecting tribal resources as a less significant factor. How would this development impact the interpretation of tribal immunity discussed in the passage?
Updated On: Sep 13, 2024
- It would support the assertion that tribal immunity is based solely on historical sovereignty.
- It would contradict the assertion that tribal immunity includes protecting tribal resources.
- It would neither support nor contradict the assertion that tribal immunity is broader than immunity enjoyed by states.
- It would support the assertion that tribal immunity can be waived through implied consent.
Hide Solution
Verified By Collegedunia
The Correct Option is B
Solution and Explanation
The Correct Option is (B):It would contradict the assertion that tribal immunity includes protecting tribal resources.
Was this answer helpful?
0
0
Question: 4
In the context of the passage, the phrase "proprietary acts" most likely refers to:
In the context of the passage, the phrase "proprietary acts" most likely refers to:
Updated On: Sep 13, 2024
- actions undertaken by Native American tribes that are commercial or private in nature.
- legislative actions taken by Congress to regulate tribal sovereignty.
- judicial decisions that uphold tribal immunity in court cases.
- federal regulations that govern tribal lands and resources.
Hide Solution
Verified By Collegedunia
The Correct Option is A
Solution and Explanation
The Correct Option is (A):actions undertaken by Native American tribes that are commercial or private in nature.
Was this answer helpful?
0
0
Top Questions on Reading Comprehension
- This particular scepticism of the reach of reasoning ____1 ____ not yield nor (as Appiah makes clear) is it intended to yield any ground for not using reason to the extent one can, in ____ 2 ____ the idea of justice or any other notion of social relevance,such as identity.Nor does it undermine the case for our trying to persuade each other to scrutinize our respective conclusions.It is also important to note that what may appear to others as clear examples of 'unreason' may not always be exactly that.Reasoned discussion can accommodate conflicting positions that may appear to others to be 'unreasoned prejudice,without this being quite the case.There is no compulsion, as is sometimes____3____to eliminate every reasoned alternative except exactly one.
In the above passage there are blanks, each of which has been numbered.Find out the appropriate option in each case to replace the given numbers.
Pick the appropriate replacement for (II)- CMAT - 2024
- Language Comprehension
- Reading Comprehension
- Read the following passage and answer the following questions by choosing the most appropriate answer.
Linguistics, an intricate and ever-evolving academic discipline, has undergone a remarkable transformation in recent decades, transcending its origins as a mere study of language to become a profound exploration of the complexities of human cognition and communication. The expanding purview of linguistics is a testament to its growing significance in understanding our world and enhancing our technological prowess. One of the most fundamental paradigm shift within linguistics has been its transition from a prescriptive to a descriptive approach. Early linguistic studies, embodied by the structuralist principles of Ferdinand de Saussure, predominantly focused on normative rules and language structures. However, the advent of modern linguistics, spearheaded by Noam Chomsky’s groundbreaking generative grammar theory, has heralded a new era of linguistic inquiry—one that seeks to understand not how languages should be used but how they are used in practice. This transformation has enabled linguists to uncover the underlying universals that govern human language, revealing its intricate tapestry. The synergy between linguistics and computer science has been instrumental in shaping our digital age. The birth of computational linguistics has given rise to transformative technologies, such as machine translation, speech recognition, and sentiment analysis. These applications, weaving the intricacies of human language with cutting-edge technology, have revolutionised fields as diverse as e-commerce, healthcare, and social media. The confluence of linguistics and computer science continues to chart new frontiers, shedding light on the symbiotic relationship between humans and machines. Moreover, interdisciplinary collaborations have propelled linguistics into uncharted territories. Cognitive linguistics marries linguistic theory with insights from psychology, neuroscience, and anthropology, unravelling the profound interplay between language and human cognition. Sociolinguistics and anthropological linguistics delve into the social and cultural dimensions of language, elucidating linguistic variations and their socio-cultural implications. This interdisciplinary nexus enriches our understanding of how language permeates all facets of human life.- AILET BALLB (Hons.) - 2024
- English
- Reading Comprehension
- Read the following passage and answer the following questions by choosing the most appropriate answer.
It is not surprising that students are experiencing a wide range of mental health challenges, such as paralyzing stress, anxiety and depression. In 2021-22, the National Health Survey found that college students’ anxiety and depression were at historic levels, with 37 percent reporting some anxiety and 44 percent experiencing some depression in the two weeks prior to the survey. Moreover, approximately 83 percent reported that emotional or mental difficulties had impaired their academic performance at some time during the month prior to taking the survey. Although some observers might try to dismiss these statistics as just a result of the pandemic, national data suggest that mental health issues were on the rise before the virus arrived. It is vital that institutions pay more attention and take more responsibility for their part in causing these trends. Research in this area suggests that cultivating caring, affirming and connected communities on college campuses is critical when it comes to mental health. Networks of professors, staff and fellow students who care can become lifelines when college stressors become all consuming. And if colleges affirm student cultures, values and identities, they can boost students’ self-esteem and sense of empowerment, help them feel less isolated and promote a greater sense of belonging. Prioritizing caring, connected and affirming communities helps more students thrive. A curriculum that allows students to simultaneously deepen their connections to their community’s cultural values and their learning environment can help them feel like they belong to both. Research also shows that culturally relevant learning experiences improve academic success. Campuses therefore should provide mental health services that are culturally responsive, via professionals who understand diverse student backgrounds and experiences. Offering counselling services, support groups and outreach programs designed for diverse communities can help students feel understood and supported.- AILET BALLB (Hons.) - 2024
- English
- Reading Comprehension
- Read the following passage and answer the following questions by choosing the most appropriate answer.
In recent years, electric vehicles (EVs) have emerged as a catalyst for change, not only in terms of sustainable transportation but also in empowering individuals to become micro-entrepreneurs. Particularly in Tier 2 markets, where access to traditional job opportunities may be limited, EVs have opened up new avenues for women to assert their economic independence and contribute significantly to household income. According to our data, an inspiring 25% of women in these markets have embraced the EV platform as a means to earn their livelihoods. Electric vehicles, be it e-rickshaws, e-carts, or e-bikes, offer an affordable and eco-friendly mode of transportation that can be easily adopted by individuals. This has allowed women to enter various service sectors like last-mile delivery, transportation, and local commuting, empowering them to generate income and uplift their communities.- AILET BALLB (Hons.) - 2024
- English
- Reading Comprehension
- Read the given extract and answer the following questions by choosing the most appropriate answer.
Why do we relentlessly pursue these gleaming awards and coveted certificates? These tokens of recognition, ranging from simple course completion certificates to the grandeur of global trophies, what drives us? Do we not have an innate sense of our own value? The human pursuit of accolades and certificates, an intricate interplay of self-worth, external validation, and societal pressures. At the heart of our chase for these honours lies an unquenchable thirst for acknowledgment and validation. No matter how confident or self-assured one may be, the allure of external validation is irresistible. It’s not about doubting our capabilities; it’s about the affirmation that our dedication and hard work have been seen, recognized, and applauded. In this light, awards and certificates stand not just as tokens but as symbols of our relentless pursuit of excellence. Our relentless pursuit of accolades is deeply woven into the fabric of our society. From an early age, we are indoctrinated to compete, to shine in academics, sports, or our careers. Society’s measure of success often hinges on these tangible milestones, which illustrate our ability not just to meet but to exceed expectations. Moreover, these recognitions bestow an unparalleled sense of accomplishment and pride. They are emblematic of the tireless hours, the unwavering dedication, and the indomitable spirit invested in chasing our dreams. This recognition is transformative, elevating an individual’s self-esteem, inspiring them to reach for the stars, and to redefine their self-worth. The satisfaction gleaned from these acknowledgments extends beyond the realm of external validation; it is an ode to personal growth. However, as we embark on this relentless journey, we must tread with caution. A relentless pursuit of external validation can lead to a superficial sense of self-worth. A person’s true worth cannot be distilled from the certificates adorning their walls or the trophies glittering on their shelves. Intrinsic motivation and personal fulfilment must hold equal sway. To conclude, our burning desire for awards and certificates mirrors our unyielding quest for recognition, validation, and the unquenchable sense of accomplishment they bring. These accolades undeniably hold great significance, but we must not forget that our self-worth should not be tethered solely to the whims of external validation. Our achievements are undeniably important, but they represent just one facet of our intricate, multi-dimensional identities.- AILET BALLB (Hons.) - 2024
- English
- Reading Comprehension
View More Questions
Questions Asked in CAT exam
- The equation \(x^3+(2r+1)x^2+(4r-1)x+2=0\) has -2 as one of the roots. If the other two roots are real, then the minimum possible non-negative integer value of \(r\) is
- CAT - 2023
- Linear & Quadratic Equations
- An air conditioner (AC) company has four dealers - D1, D2, D3 and D4 in a city. It is evaluating sales performances of these dealers. The company sells two variants of ACs Window and Split. Both these variants can be either Inverter type or Non-inverter type. It is known that of the total number of ACs sold in the city, 25% were of Window variant, while the rest were of Split variant. Among the Inverter ACs sold, 20% were of Window variant.
The following information is also known:
1. Every dealer sold at least two window ACs.
2. D1 sold 13 inverter ACs, while D3 sold 5 Non-inverter ACs.
3. A total of six Window Non-inverter ACs and 36 Split Inverter ACs were sold in the city. 4. The number of Split ACs sold by D1 was twice the number of Window ACs sold by it. 5. D3 and D4 sold an equal number of Window ACs and this number was one-third of the number of similar ACs sold by D2.
4. D2 and D3 were the only ones who sold Window Non-inverter ACs. The number of these ACs sold by D2 was twice the number of these ACs sold by D3.
5. D3 and D4 sold an equal number of Split Inverter ACs. This number was half the number of similar ACs sold by D2
What was the total number of ACs sold by D2 and D4? (This Question was asked as TITA)- CAT - 2023
- Data Analysis
- There are nine boxes arranged in a 3×3 array as shown in Tables 1 and 2. Each box contains three sacks. Each sack has a certain number of coins, between 1 and 9, both inclusive.
The average number of coins per sack in the boxes are all distinct integers. The total number of coins in each row is the same. The total number of
coins in each column is also the same.
Table 1 gives information regarding the median of the numbers of coins in the three sacks in a box for some of the boxes. In Table 2 each box has a number which represents the number of sacks in that box having more than 5 coins. That number is followed by a * if the sacks in that box satisfy exactly one among the following three conditions, and it is followed by ** if two or more of these conditions are satisfied.
i) The minimum among the numbers of coins in the three sacks in the box is 1.
ii) The median of the numbers of coins in the three sacks is 1.
iii) The maximum among the numbers of coins in the three sacks in the box is 9.
How many sacks have exactly one coin?[This Question was asked as TITA]- CAT - 2023
- Data Analysis
- There are only three female students - Amala, Koli and Rini - and only three male students - Biman, Mathew and Shyamal - in a course. The course has two evaluation components, a project and a test. The aggregate score in the course is a weighted average of the two components, with the weights being positive and adding to 1 .
The projects are done in groups of two, with each group consisting of a female and a male student. Both the group members obtain the same score in the project.
The following additional facts are known about the scores in the project and the test.
1. The minimum, maximum and the average of both project and test scores were identical – 40, 80 and 60 , respectively.
2. The test scores of the students were all multiples of 10 ; four of them were distinct and the remaining two were equal to the average test scores.
3. Amala's score in the project was double that of Koli in the same, but Koli scored 20 more than Amala in the test. Yet Amala had the highest aggregate score.
4. Shyamal scored the second highest in the test. He scored two more than Koli, but two less than Amala in the aggregate.
5. Biman scored the second lowest in the test and the lowest in the aggregate.
6. Mathew scored more than Rini in the project, but less than her in the test.
What was Mathew's score in the test?(This Question was asked as TITA)- CAT - 2023
- Data Analysis
- There are nine boxes arranged in a 3×3 array as shown in Tables 1 and 2. Each box contains three sacks. Each sack has a certain number of coins, between 1 and 9, both inclusive.
The average number of coins per sack in the boxes are all distinct integers. The total number of coins in each row is the same. The total number of
coins in each column is also the same.
Table 1 gives information regarding the median of the numbers of coins in the three sacks in a box for some of the boxes. In Table 2 each box has a number which represents the number of sacks in that box having more than 5 coins. That number is followed by a * if the sacks in that box satisfy exactly one among the following three conditions, and it is followed by ** if two or more of these conditions are satisfied.
i) The minimum among the numbers of coins in the three sacks in the box is 1.
ii) The median of the numbers of coins in the three sacks is 1.
iii) The maximum among the numbers of coins in the three sacks in the box is 9.
In how many boxes do all three sacks contain different numbers of coins? [This Question was asked as TITA]- CAT - 2023
- Data Analysis
View More Questions
CAT Notification
CAT 2024 Registration Extended till Sept 20, Apply Now!Sep 13, 2024IIM Calcutta has extended CAT 2024 registration last date to September 20, 2024. Interested and eligible candidates can apply online on the official website iimcat.ac.in
SUBSCRIBE TO OUR NEWS LETTER
COLLEGE NOTIFICATIONSEXAM NOTIFICATIONSNEWS UPDATES
Download the Collegedunia app on 
© 2024 Collegedunia Web Pvt. Ltd. All Rights Reserved